Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Paul Millerd's avatar

Interesting enough Maslow seemed more confused closer to death than near certainty. I think he was spot on with the b values but so t think I’d map them to a pyramid. It’s more like you need a portal to get there (maybe a sabbatical or quitting your job!).

This is where all social science theories fall flat. They make some elementary assumptions about what a “normal” adult should be doing.

Expand full comment
KimSia Sim's avatar

Google herzberg two factors theory

It’s essentially the same thing but more precise than millerds

Let me give a very summarized version of herzberg

Most people think happy and unhappy are two ends of the same spectrum hence opposite of happy is unhappy

Herzberg theory says happy and unhappy are actually their own separate spectrums (once you understand this, everything else becomes easy to understand and remember)

So you have happy vs not happy as two ends of one spectrum

Unhappy vs not unhappy as two ends of a diff spectrum

Happy spectrum affected by meaning related factors like purpose etc

Unhappy spectrum affected by hygiene factors like money

Think of a 2x2 where your axes are happy and unhappy axes

So you have

Quadrant 1: happy and not unhappy (ideal situation)

Q2: not happy and not unhappy (think abt your rich but unfulfilled banker as stereotype)

Q3: unhappy and happy (think abt your dirt poor social worker who has issues making rent but making an impact in community)

Q4: unhappy and not happy (worst case - poorly paid in unfulfilling job)

You can of course do the Maslow pyramid thing and start by concentrating on solving hygiene factor problem first

But I don’t think it’s a one size fits all

I have seen people who focus on solving for meaning first because somehow they will auto (and indeed) end up solving hygiene factors along the way

Even the same person may end up changing their approach because their experiences n strengths n commitments are different at different stages of their life

Expand full comment
24 more comments...

No posts